CADP banner graphic
 

News

Colorado’s Death Row

Nathan Dunlap was convicted and sentenced to death in 1996 for the murder of four employees at an Aurora Chuck E. Cheese's restaurant.

Related Stories

  • About Broken Links
  • Dunlap Execution Date Set
    Littleton -- A district court judge has scheduled condemned murderer Nathan Dunlap's execution for the week of Feb. 27. The Associated Press story also quotes Rebecca Oakes, the daughter of one of the murder victims. "I'm not on a crusade to save the life of Nathan Dunlap," she said. "I'm just opposed to the death penalty." (11/19/99, The Daily Camera)
  • CO High Court Upholds Dunlap's Death Sentence
    DENVER -- The state Supreme Court on Monday upheld the death sentence for Nathan Dunlap who was convicted of murdering four people at a suburban family pizza restaurant.Dunlap had asked the justices to commute his death sentence and additional 113 years, claiming the trial court abused its discretion by refusing to hear additional evidence about factors that could have spared his life. (9/11/01, The Daily Camera)
  • Jury in the Dark?
    Now, nearly 10 years after the crime, Nathan Dunlap's appeals attorney is arguing that jurors might have spared him if they had heard more than just hints of the killer's horrific life - if they had understood what was behind that disturbing smile. Death penalty appeals are often dry and legalistic. But this one tells a harrowing story. Dunlap suffered a childhood of beatings by a 300-pound stepfather and a violent, delusional and sexually abusive mother, according to documents filed in his appeal. Dunlap's mother, grandfather and uncle all had been hospitalized repeatedly with diagnoses of violent, paranoid manic depression or schizophrenia, the appeal says. (6/28/03, Rocky Mountain News)
  • Moans of Pain in Haven of Innocence
    When Nathan Dunlap was arrested the next day, the community was out for blood. Headlines called it a massacre, a rampage. Then-Sen. Bill Owens, who knew two of the victims from his own kids' parties at the restaurant, used the crime to call for a stronger death penalty in an editorial published on Christmas Eve. (6/28/03, Rocky Mountain News)
  • Defense, Prison Silent on Treatment
    Sides at odds over Dunlap's mental health, won't say if he's medicated. (6/28/03, Rocky Mountain News)
  • Dunlap's Defense
    Arapahoe District Judge John Leopold made the right call recently when he rejected arguments that murderer Nathan Dunlap was denied a fair trial because of ineffective defense counsel. Dunlap in fact had the benefit of experienced, skilled attorneys who worked long and hard on his case, trying to do their best in an extremely difficult defense. (8/8/04, Editorial by the Rocky Mountain News.)
  • New Appeal Filed For Man On Death Row
    The man sentenced to die for killing four people at a Chuck E. Cheese's restaurant in Aurora in 1993 is now asking a federal judge in Denver to spare his life. In a 755-page motion filed in U.S. District Court in Denver, attorneys for Nathan Dunlap list 41 reasons his death sentence should be thrown out, including that his original defense attorneys were ineffective. The appeal comes one month after the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear the case, and after the Colorado Supreme Court upheld the conviction and sentence for the third time. Dunlap, now 33 and the only person on Colorado's death row, was convicted in 1996 of first-degree murder for the deaths of restaurant employees Sylvia Crowell, 19, Benjamin Grant and Colleen O'Connor, both 17, and manager Margaret Kohlberg, 50. (2/21/08, Rocky Mountain News)
  • Update on Dunlap Case (Within Owens Story)
    Nathan Dunlap was convicted of four murders in 1996 in connection with the robbery of an Aurora Chuck E Cheese in 1994. Earlier this year, the U.S. Supreme Court refused to hear Dunlap's appeal. The Colorado Supreme Court has upheld the conviction three times. Dunlap's case is now under appeal before U.S. District Judge Edward Nottingham; the judge's decision is pending. (6/16/08, Rocky Mountain News)


Search the news archives of the Boulder Daily Camera, the Denver Post, and the Denver Rocky Mountain News for additional information.





For information on other prisoners, see Colorado's Death Row.

See the Web site's News section for more articles and information about the death penalty.
 

Website copyright 1999-2010 CADP - Page updated or verified 6/16/08